First-Time Cheesecake Success: Easy, Pure-Ingredient Recipe + Honest Tips

Carmen Fourie
Jul 1
3 min read

Creamy cheesecake on a white plate, with text "healthy & easy Cheesecake" and "first time making cheesecake" against a blurred green background.

If you're looking to make a cheesecake for the first time and want something easy and beginner-friendly, this is it! I just made my first-ever cheesecake completely from scratch (including the crumb base—no store-bought cookies) using pure, healthy ingredients, and it turned out beautifully.

I’ll share the recipe I followed, the tweaks I recommend, and what I learned along the way so you can make your own perfect cheesecake without the stress (or setting off your fire alarm 😅).

Side story - I only attempted this cake because Ian's (husband) loves cheesecake but almost never eats it because we stick to healthy homemade foods. I wanted to gift him something for Father's Day that was just buying something for the sake of it - so he got a cheesecake for Father's Day and we all loved it :).

The Base Recipe I Used

I used this New York Cheesecake recipe as my starting point:

👉 Of Batter and Dough: New York Cheesecake

It’s a classic, very approachable recipe, even for total beginners. But I’d suggest a few modifications, especially if you’re using a toaster oven or want an extra crisp crust.

Ingredients I Recommend

I wanted to keep everything as clean and simple as possible, no weird additives or gums.

Here’s what I used:

✅ Flour: Scottish Mill Unfortified Organic Unbleached Flour

✅ Cream Cheese: Tre Stelle Organic — no additives or gums

Everything else was standard whole-food ingredients—organic sugar (Costco), eggs (free range), butter (organic), etc. No pre-made cookies in the base. You’ll make a proper crumb crust from scratch with this flour!

Stack of Tre Stelle cream cheese on a countertop beside a laptop and kitchen scale. Blue packaging with bagel image.

Note: While we love grassfed butter for health in this home it can be expensive and therefore for baking I buy organic, but not necessarily grassfed and then we buy grass-fed butter for eating raw with dates or on toast.

Suggested Changes to the Original Recipe

While the base recipe is excellent, I’d recommend these tweaks based on my first-time experience:

1️⃣ Bake the Crust a Little Longer

The original time left it a bit softer than I wanted.
Tip: Add a few extra minutes for a more crisp, sturdy base.

Dough in a red bowl on a kitchen counter with fork marks. A laptop in the background is partially visible, creating a casual cooking scene.

2️⃣ Adjust the Baking Temperature and Time

The recipe calls for an initial blast at 475 °F.
Even though my XL toaster oven only goes to 450 °F, that was still too hot!
It burned the top a little and even set off our fire alarm.

My solution:✅ Quick high-heat blast to set the top (carefully watched)✅ Then lowered the oven to a much lower temperature and let it bake slowly for nearly 3 hours to set properly.

My main advice? Don't rush it! Cheesecake wants gentle, patient heat. Lower and slower is safer and gives a creamy result without scorching.

3️⃣ Toaster Oven Tip

I actually used our XL toaster oven for this whole bake!
- P.S. Our toaster oven has been the purchase of the year! It completely replaced our toaster, microwave and large oven. We use it daily and I highly recommend it - especially because of it's size.
Just watch the top carefully at the start and lower the heat as soon as it browns.

No Cake Tin? No Problem!

I don’t even own a proper cake tin!

I used:

✅ A silicone baking “pan”

✅ Buttered well along the sides and bottom

✅ Lined the bottom with silicone parchment for extra non-stick help

It worked perfectly. The cheesecake released easily with no sticking at all.

Batter-filled red silicone cake mold on a black tray on a kitchen counter. Blurred background with a wooden holder and glass jug.

My Verdict

⭐ Super easy to make — nothing complicated about mixing the ingredients

⭐ The only hard part is the waiting for it to bake and cool!

⭐ Tastes incredible — classic, rich, creamy cheesecake with real, clean ingredients

Final Tips for Fellow First-Time Bakers

✨ Don’t be afraid to make it from scratch — it’s genuinely simple.

✨ Use the best quality, most natural ingredients you can find.

✨ Plan ahead: it takes time in the oven and needs to chill fully.

✨ Be patient with the baking temperature — lower and slower is better than risking a burnt top.

If you’re craving a cheesecake that’s truly homemade (no cookies in the crust, no gums in the cheese), give this a try!

I hope these notes help you bake something delicious, with no surprises (except how easy it actually is!).

Slice of cheesecake on a plate with a fork. The plate reads "TODAY IS A GOOD DAY." Background is blurred, wooden surface visible.

Hope you enjoy making this and eating it!

Let me know what you think!

Carmen

Affiliate Disclaimer:

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I use and love. Thank you for supporting this site!